COMPLIANCELEMON SQUEEZYPADDLE

Lemon Squeezy to Paddle: how to migrate your subscriptions

How to move from Lemon Squeezy to Paddle before March 31, 2027: assisted or customer-led migration, keeping billing dates, PayPal and what to rebuild.

Published 6 min read

Lemon Squeezy to Paddle: how to migrate your subscriptions

Paddle is the closest like-for-like move from Lemon Squeezy: it is also a merchant of record, it supports PayPal, and it charges 5% + 50¢ per transaction with no monthly or migration fee. Card subscriptions can move without customers re-entering their card through a Paddle-assisted migration, for eligible stores. Everything else, including PayPal and Cash App Pay subscriptions, moves through a customer-led migration: the customer subscribes again through a Paddle checkout and you cancel the old subscription. Lemon Squeezy stops processing on March 31, 2027.

This guide covers both paths, how to keep customers’ billing dates, how Lemon Squeezy concepts map to Paddle, and what you have to rebuild. For the dates and the other options, see Lemon Squeezy is shutting down.

Which migration path should you choose?

Your situation Path
Most subscriptions are paid by card, and you don’t want customers to re-enter details Paddle-assisted migration, if a Paddle specialist confirms your store is eligible
Smaller store, gradual move, or subscriptions not paid by card Customer-led migration

Most migrations use both at once: Paddle imports the card subscriptions while customers paying another way subscribe again. Lemon Squeezy also asks merchants moving to another provider to fill in its migration intake form, under My account > Settings > Migration. Only card subscriptions can be migrated to another provider.

Two ways to move subscriptions to Paddle
  1. 01 Assisted: card subscriptions Card details move vault to vault, customers don't re-enter them
  2. 02 Assisted: import file One row per subscription, with Paddle price IDs
  3. 03 Customer-led: any payment method The customer subscribes again through a Paddle checkout
  4. 04 Customer-led: keep the billing date Zero price first, then the real price with do_not_bill
  5. 05 Both: cancel on Lemon Squeezy Only once the Paddle subscription exists

How does a Paddle-assisted migration work?

It has three parts: card details move from Lemon Squeezy’s payment processor to Paddle’s vault, you send a file of subscriber data, and Paddle runs an import that matches the two. Card details move between the vaults directly; you never handle them.

  1. Request the migration. A specialist reviews your setup, confirms eligibility and sends the import template. The timing depends mostly on how fast Lemon Squeezy provides the export.
  2. Recreate your catalog. Create Paddle products and prices matching the variants your subscribers are on, legacy prices included, plus any discounts to carry over. The import file uses the IDs from your live Paddle account, not the sandbox.
  3. Go live on Paddle. The import can’t run until new customers go through a Paddle checkout and nothing new is sold on Lemon Squeezy. Before the import date, set up your retention settings and check the tax_mode on your prices: imported subscriptions use them from their first renewal.
  4. Prepare the subscriber file. One row per subscription: email, country and postal code (taken from the orders export, because the Lemon Squeezy API doesn’t return them), status, currency, a next billing date in the future, Paddle price IDs and quantities, and the Lemon Squeezy IDs as external IDs. Expect a test import on a sample first.
  5. Import day. A subscription.imported event fires for each subscription, and you get a file mapping Lemon Squeezy subscription IDs to Paddle IDs. Update your database and keep the old IDs for support.
  6. Stop billing on Lemon Squeezy. Cancel the matching Lemon Squeezy subscriptions. A cancelled one keeps access until the end of its paid period. Agree with your specialist how to handle subscriptions renewing close to the import date, which could be billed by both platforms.

Canceled subscriptions aren’t imported. For any subscription whose card details didn’t transfer, fall back to the customer-led path.

How does a customer-led migration work?

The customer starts a new subscription through a Paddle checkout, and you cancel the old one. It works for any payment method, and you control the timing.

  • Build one migration checkout in your app, opened for the price matching the customer’s Lemon Squeezy variant, with their email prefilled and your own customer ID passed as custom data.
  • Ask at natural moments: wherever the customer would otherwise meet Lemon Squeezy in your app, such as the payment method update button, the plan change screen or a failed payment.
  • Ask directly too: email customers with a link to the migration checkout, early enough to follow up those who ignore it before the deadline.
  • Cancel the old subscription when subscription.created fires, matched through the custom data.

Don’t block access until customers subscribe again: Paddle’s own guide warns that it causes churn. Expect some customers to miss the message, and some dormant subscribers to cancel once reminded.

How do you avoid charging customers twice?

A new Paddle subscription bills immediately. For a customer who has already paid Lemon Squeezy for the current period, Paddle’s guide gives a way to keep their renewal date:

  1. Create a recurring price of zero, and open the migration checkout for it. The customer saves their card and isn’t charged.
  2. When subscription.created fires, replace the zero price with the real one, with proration_billing_mode set to do_not_bill.
  3. Set next_billed_at to the Lemon Squeezy subscription’s renews_at, again with do_not_bill. Paddle rejects a date less than 30 minutes away.

The customer is first billed on their existing renewal date. Paddle emails them at each step, so tell them to expect those emails. Trialing and paused subscriptions have their own variants of this in Paddle’s guide.

How do Lemon Squeezy concepts map to Paddle?

Lemon Squeezy Paddle Billing
Products with variants Products with prices; variants differing only by price or period become prices on one product, variants differing by features become separate products
Storefront and product pages None: Paddle Checkout opens as an overlay or inline on a page you host, with Paddle.js
checkout[custom][user_id] customData at checkout, copied to the subscription and returned in webhooks
Orders and subscription invoices Transactions; renewals have the origin subscription_recurring, refunds are adjustments
Statuses on_trial, active, paused, past_due, unpaid, cancelled, expired Statuses trialing, active, past_due, paused, canceled
An unpaid subscription Paused or canceled after dunning, depending on your settings

What do you have to rebuild?

  • License keys, files and download links. Not part of Paddle. Paddle tells you when a purchase completes; you generate keys and host files.
  • Affiliates. Not part of Paddle. Paddle’s guide names Tolt, FirstPromoter and Partnero. Lemon Squeezy Affiliates close on March 31, 2027.
  • Email marketing. Paddle doesn’t send marketing emails. Export your subscriber list from Lemon Squeezy into your email tool.
  • History. Orders, invoices, refunds and payouts stay in Lemon Squeezy. Export what you need before access ends.

How NoChurn helps

NoChurn connects to both Lemon Squeezy and Paddle. Its cancel flows and win-back emails can keep working through the move, and a win-back sequence can remind customers who still need to go through the migration checkout.

FAQ

Does Paddle support PayPal?

Yes, at checkout in supported currencies, alongside cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay and local payment methods. But PayPal subscriptions can’t be transferred from Lemon Squeezy: those customers subscribe again through a Paddle checkout.

Do Paddle fees differ from Lemon Squeezy’s?

Paddle charges 5% + 50¢ per transaction, with no monthly fee and no migration fee. Lemon Squeezy charges 5% + 50¢, plus 1.5% for international transactions, 1.5% for PayPal and 0.5% for subscription payments.

What happens to cancelled Lemon Squeezy subscriptions?

They aren’t imported. Only active, trialing, paused or past due card subscriptions can go through an assisted import.

How long does it take?

Lemon Squeezy estimates up to eight weeks for a migration. With an assisted migration, the transfer time depends mostly on how fast Lemon Squeezy provides the card data export.

Sources

All accessed 22 November 2026.

PROMPT

Read https://www.nochurn.sh/llms.txt,
then follow https://docs.nochurn.sh/quickstart/
to add NoChurn to this app. Use a test key
(nc_test_…) until I say we go live.

Stop leaking revenue.

  • Free until $300 MRR
  • No card needed
  • Live in 10 minutes
  • No commission